Wednesday, 30 June 2010
Historical Methodology and the Believer
by Ibn Warraq (July 2010)


The following is an expanded version of the speech Mr. Warraq delivered to the 2010 New English Review Symposium, "Decline, Fall & Islam" on June 19, 2010.


PART ONE: SCIENTIFIC METHODOLOGY
 
A few years ago I was invited to a conference at The Hague by Professor Hans Jansen, the great Arabist. After listening to series of grim papers all day long, Hans and I headed for the nearest bar. I was to give my talk the next day and I asked him what I should talk about. He replied, you must begin with a joke, there were not enough jokes. So I shall begin with a joke, first told me by Joe Hoffmann, which in fact is relevant to the theme of my present paper, that is, historical methodology, and the consequences of scientific research into the origins of early Islam and Christianity, consequences for the believer above all.  more>>>
Posted on 06/30/2010 4:15 PM by NER
Comments
9 Jul 2010
Send an emailCharles Cherry

Warriq's article is good, but he seems to be unacquainted with much New Testament scholarship of the last twenty years. Men like Larry Hurtado ("Lord Jesus Christ") have ably shown that the Christian Scriptures are much earlier than previously claimed, and that the oral sources behind the early writings give even greater creedence to the authenticity and credibility of the Synoptic Gospels and the letters of Paul. 

Paul's letters show a heavy dependence on early Jewish Christianity (which had to have arisen, based on the literary evidence alone, within a decade or so of the Resurrection). Paul's earliest letter, Galatians, was written in 53 or 54 - a mere twenty years after the death of Jesus, when most of the eyewitnesses were still alive and well. 

Christianity, unlike Islam, stands or falls on the historical record, and so far it has stood the test quite well, thank you.



9 Nov 2010
Send an emailMike Lotrean

I like Ibn Warraq's article but am surprised he doesn't know that the book by Luxenberg was published English in 2007 as The Syro-Aramaic Reading of the Koran: A contribution to the decoding of the Language of the Koran and is readily available