Thursday, 5 July 2007
Faith and Doctrine

A couple of times recently, in regard to (a) Islam, and (b) Christianity, I've passed comment on the distance between the doctrines of religions, and the understandings of ordinary believers.

Charles Murray has a relevant footnote on this in the exchanges over at Commentary about his "Jewish Genius" piece.

"During six years of working in Thai villages and living within the Thai community in Bangkok, I met no lay person who knew more than the Buddhist equivalent of Sunday-school stories about the teachings of his religion. The Buddhist texts are indeed as harrowingly complex as Mr. Barnes says, and the practice of Buddhist meditation can be a profound intellectual and spiritual experience, but reading the texts and meditating are optional. Being a Buddhist in good standing is easy."
Posted on 07/05/2007 9:32 AM by John Derbyshire
Comments
5 Jul 2007
Reactionry
Concern For Bangladesh*
Edifice Schmidifice -As Long As He Loves His Mantra
 
I wonder if Murray spent any time in southern Thailand among Muslim peasants.  Those who missed Rebecca Bynum's link to Zinoviev's piece might do well to scroll down to "About the Arabisation of Indian Consciousness."  What were those lyrics? - "A night away from Bangkok makes a humble man hard"?
And are those Thai villagers ignorant of the explosive implications of the edifice complex exhibited by the Taliban in Afghanistan? 
 
*Few remember the 1972 "Countries of Concern" tour organized by Madeleine Albright, Harrison (no -not George - the other one: Tinsley Randolph H. IV) and a very young Axl "Of Evil" Rose, long before there was even a glimmer of Guns 'N Moses.
 
 
 


5 Jul 2007
Reactionry
Oops.  It figures that one of the "dumbest" and "stupidest," accustomed to remembering "little parts," spirochetes and wot not, would have forgotten the bit part played by Ravi Chancre.